About Us


Each of our staff members are valuable assets to our church and its ministries. Without their dedication and willingness to serve, grow, and lead, our congregation would be lost indeed. Thank you, staff, for all your time and commitment to our ministries for Christ in this church and in the community.

Rev. Bob Thomson, Sr. Pastor / Head of Staff
Pastor Bob is committed to First Presbyterian Church glorifying God through its Worship, Christian Education, and Mission outreach. In the Great Commission Christ called his church to go make disciples in all the world. First Presbyterian is dedicated to growing faithful disciples who serve as ambassadors for Christ in Cheyenne and in the world. Pastor Bob and his wife Kellie are new to Cheyenne and are blessed with two teenage daughters and a son who is twelve. “Our family enjoys camping, bicycling, and enjoying the great outdoors.” If you are looking for a church to call home, we invite you to come as you are to worship and experience the love of Jesus Christ.

Rev. Diana Hartman, Associate Pastor
Diana Hartman brings her passion and creativity to her position as Associate Pastor at First Presbyterian Church.  In addition to sharing preaching, worship leadership and compassionate pastoral care with the Head-of Staff Pastor, she enjoys teaching, local mission, and promoting fellowship among and beyond the congregation. She works with the Small Group, Deacon, and New Life Ministries.  She is passionate about helping people discover  their spiritual gifts and connecting them with opportunities to use their gifts in compassionate service. Active in the life of the Presbytery, she has served on Presbytery council and on several committees. Diana worked as a computer programmer, systems analyst, and teacher’s associate prior to her call to ministry.  Diana and her husband Paul are proud parents of three adult children and enjoy three grandchildren.  Diana enjoys reading, weaving, traveling, and baking.

Ashley Braisted, Children’s Ministry Director
Ashley has an enormous heart for children and enjoys watching them grow spiritually. Your children will want to be a part of all the new and exciting activities she has planned. Children are very important to us and we are excited to have Ashley teaching and guiding our children.

Matthew Woodard, Youth Ministry Director
Matt is the Director of the Youth Ministry program, which includes Youth Group, Sunday School, and various Bible studies. He has lots of energy and is excited to lead our youth in a wide variety of ways. Matt leads this group in most all activities concerning youth, including onsite church activities, as well as youth trips for mission work or retreats. He is excited to work so much with the youth, and hopes that he can share that excitement with you, too!

ShelLu Arrowsmith, Executive Assistant
ShelLu assists the Head of Staff and other office personnel with various projects, updating lists, and supporting members. She is also charged with accountability and accuracy for many items viewed by the membership: newsletters, bulletins, announcements, calendars, and various monthly and annual reports. She often serves as the liaison between staff, projects, and members. Her job is made easier through the graciousness of the staff, the wonderful volunteers, and the welcoming membership. ShelLu says she is blessed to work with a busy congregation with so many projects that help those in need. She relocated to Cheyenne from Torrington with her husband, and three furry family members, in late 2015.

George Barnes, Clerk of Session
George’s responsibilities include keeping the minutes of the meetings for the Session and Congregation, keeping the church records, and being one of the chief officers of the church. George ’s dedication to this job is important to keeping our record books in order.

Greg Dyekman, Treasurer
Responsible for overseeing our finances, with the help of the Finance Committee, Greg also makes sure each week that our offerings are faithfully counted and deposited. Stewardship and accountability are his key words.

Betty Jo Mainwaring, Bookkeeper
(307) 638-3345
Betty Jo is the keeper of the financial accounts for our church. All expenses are submitted to her so that we can be good stewards of the financial support our members and friends provide for our church and its ministries.

Becky Tish, Choir and Handbell Director
Music is deeply planted within Becky’s heart and soul. You can see it as she oversees our entire music program as she directs our Chancel and Handbell Choirs. Her gift of music is shared in making our services more meaningful by the excellent selections of music she provides each week for the choir.

Becky is also the inspiration behind our melodious ringers. With the ringtones of an adult handbell choir, our congregation is treated to a regular rendition of some of our favorite hymns played on the bells.

Eleanor Lane, Organist
Eleanor Lane, a life-long member of First Presbyterian Church, is the principal organist/pianist who provides service music for worship, as well as accompanying the chancel choir, soloists, and small groups. She is available to play for weddings, funerals, and other special events, and she is responsible for programming the carillon for changes in seasonal music.

Michael Honeycutt, Custodian
Born and raised in Laramie, Wyoming; moved to Denver, Colorado in 1990 where I spent the majority of my time working in the security fields as a protective force officer and a security manager. I returned to Wyoming in 2017. I enjoy writing TV and movie scripts, non-professionally, and listening to all genres of music.

Willie Banks, Custodian
Helping out on Sunday morning is Willie. By arriving early and getting things set up and ready to go, our members and friends arrive at a church building that is ready to receive them and make them feel welcome.

Mission Statement

As followers of Jesus Christ, under the authority of the Bible, our mission is

  • Glorifying and worshiping God
  • Baptizing and strengthening disciples
  • Loving and serving all people

Vision Statement

  • Vibrant Worship
  • Vibrant Discipleship
  • Vibrant Service


First Church of Cheyenne was the first Presbyterian Church to be organized in the Territory of Wyoming on July 18, 1869 with nine charter members. The first building on the northeast corner of Eighteenth and Ferguson (Carey Ave.) was dedicated on July 17, 1870 at a cost of $6500.00. The church was named the Krebs Memorial Presbyterian Church, as a memorial to the lamented Dr. Krebs whose former congregation, the Rutgers Church of New York, contributed largely to the building of this church. Rev. Sheldon Jackson preached the dedicatory sermon and a collection of $150.00 was taken up , which put the church out of debt.

A new church building at the same location was dedicated in 1884, having been built for a cost of $14,000.00. The size of the church was 51’x85′, with a tower, 96 feet high, and main building 52 feet high. The bell from the old church hung in 1876 was placed in the tall steeple of the new church and continued to call worshipers until the building was torn down in 1925.

The current building at 22nd and Carey was dedicated on March 22, 1925. A beautiful memorial chapel in honor of the Presbyterian boys who gave their lives in World War II was dedicated on November 10, 1948. A new Christian Education wing was dedicated on September 17, 1961.